Analysis of the Bussards Polywell (Part 2 of 3)

"Someday, they said, if they're right, a machine just 20 times bigger could run the city of Santa Fe." - The Santa Fe News Imagine if you could spend 200,000 dollars on a machine, which satisfied all your energy needs. Imagine there was a machine which produced bountiful electricity with no carbon footprint and no radiation. Imagine if that machine held the capacity to make space exploration a real possibility. If that were true, then such a machine would be the greatest invention of our time. That is a big IF. That is the claim that Dr. Robert Bussard is making with his Polywell device. He is claiming that he has designed a machine which will create bountiful energy, with no radiation and no carbon footprint. Such a claim is hard to stomach. It is hard to believe. This video attempts to take a hard look at this claim. Where does it make sense? Where does it falter? How valid is it, from a rough engineering analysis. This is by no means comprehensive. I do not claim to be an expert. Hopefully, this will spark a conversation, and further investigation by honest experts, into this validity of this device. ----------- Magnetic Containment Field: The Whiffle ball Effect This is the big question mark of the experiment. Can Dr. Bussards device create a spherical magnetic containment field? Bussard claims he can. Moreover, he claims what he created is a Whiffle ball containment field; electrons are mainly trapped, except for leak holes on the sides of the field. The leaking allows electrons to re-circulate. Bussard does give us a hint as to how it works in his Google talk: As you push the magnetic field out, the scaling ceases to be mirror scaling and becomes cusp confinement scaling that scales at 1/magnetic field strength^2.. In essence, what happens is the electron cloud in the center presses against the magnetic field. In the push and pull of forces, a Whiffle ball field is formed. It is: very much like blowing up a balloon. The Whiffle ball is also determined by the placement of the magnetic rings on the side. Their placement is critical; as Bussard explains in his letter: so that no B field uniquely penetrated the cans, and then placed the coils in a special array so that no corners touched (this latter is a long topic having to do with local B fields, and loss of Wiffle Ball trapping due to line cusp effects at the corners, etc, etc, and is the basis of our final patents on this thing). It IS the details that make or break the device. And this particular set of details absolutely dominates the performance. An analogy can be made to focusing light using lens. In the same manner, it seems the precise placement of these magnetic rings is critical to the device performance. At Google, Dr. Bussard mentions the distance between the edges as some multiple of the gyro radii.

2008/10/10 CleanEnergyFuture45   Share on Facebook

RELATED VIDEOS

Analysis of the Bussards Polywell  (Part 3 of 3)
Play Video

Analysis of the Bussards Polywell (Part 3 of 3)

2008/10/10
Analysisof the Bussards
Play Video

Analysisof the Bussards' Polywell Idea (Part 1 of 3)

2008/10/10
IEC Fusion for Dummies v5.7
Play Video

IEC Fusion for Dummies v5.7

2007/05/27
The Polywell 101
Play Video

The Polywell 101

2013/05/22
Polywell - Video Learning - WizScience.com
Play Video

Polywell - Video Learning - WizScience.com

2015/09/05
Hot Clean Fusion Energy Device
Play Video

Hot Clean Fusion Energy Device

2008/10/19
Polywell Fusion in 6 Steps :-)
Play Video

Polywell Fusion in 6 Steps :-)

2012/11/26
Polywell simulation 3D
Play Video

Polywell simulation 3D

2007/06/02
IEC Fusion vs Tokamak Fusion
Play Video

IEC Fusion vs Tokamak Fusion

2007/05/10
polywell sim   ion time scale   semi artificial anode, ions only 1
Play Video

polywell sim ion time scale semi artificial anode, ions only 1

2010/11/24
Polywell fusion simulation with CUDA (V2)
Play Video

Polywell fusion simulation with CUDA (V2)

2015/10/01
DC Park at Cameron Yards: Wiffleball
Play Video

DC Park at Cameron Yards: Wiffleball

2008/06/26
Hall Effect Sensors - Magnetic Mirrors - Pinball Bumpers
Play Video

Hall Effect Sensors - Magnetic Mirrors - Pinball Bumpers

2010/05/12
Path of an electron inside the cube polywell
Play Video

Path of an electron inside the cube polywell

2007/06/12
Open Source Nuclear Fusion
Play Video

Open Source Nuclear Fusion

2012/04/04
SPSU (Southern Poly) Well Control Technology
Play Video

SPSU (Southern Poly) Well Control Technology

2010/11/24
KAGJAK Field: Rocheter
Play Video

KAGJAK Field: Rocheter's BEST Wiffle Ball Field

2008/09/07
Rake the Catcher Area and the Pitcher Mound
Play Video

Rake the Catcher Area and the Pitcher Mound

2009/03/20
Fusion Particle Simulation with CUDA
Play Video

Fusion Particle Simulation with CUDA

2012/07/18
Polywell Nuclear Fusion Reactor 3D Simulation
Play Video

Polywell Nuclear Fusion Reactor 3D Simulation

2008/04/17
how to make a pitchers mound
Play Video

how to make a pitchers mound

2008/03/03
Part 4/4: Fusion taking focus - The Fall 2010 update!
Play Video

Part 4/4: Fusion taking focus - The Fall 2010 update!

2010/10/15
Focus Fusion: The Fastest Route to Cheap, Clean Energy
Play Video

Focus Fusion: The Fastest Route to Cheap, Clean Energy

2012/08/22
2007 Google Tech Talk: Focus Fusion - The Fastest Route to Cheap, Clean Energy?
Play Video

2007 Google Tech Talk: Focus Fusion - The Fastest Route to Cheap, Clean Energy?

2011/04/21
The Bussard
Play Video

The Bussard

2011/12/02
Magnetic Fields - test1 (blue and green, both are electrons)
Play Video

Magnetic Fields - test1 (blue and green, both are electrons)

2009/01/08
Aneutronic Nuclear Fusion Reactor + Engine Proposal
Play Video

Aneutronic Nuclear Fusion Reactor + Engine Proposal

2013/05/31
Camp Jewell Wiffle Ball: The Awakening
Play Video

Camp Jewell Wiffle Ball: The Awakening

2009/04/20
Stille Stadium Field
Play Video

Stille Stadium Field

2008/10/02
The Commercial Polywell Reactor
Play Video

The Commercial Polywell Reactor

2012/12/05
Polywell B150L2-i7 Review
Play Video

Polywell B150L2-i7 Review

2016/01/28
Mark Suppes: I still don
Play Video

Mark Suppes: I still don't know everything I should | WIRED 2012 | WIRED

2012/11/23
Back yard wiffle ball
Play Video

Back yard wiffle ball

2009/09/05
System Control Theory and Networked Robotics
Play Video

System Control Theory and Networked Robotics

2010/01/20
hit in face with wiffle ball bat
Play Video

hit in face with wiffle ball bat

2008/11/07
Dr. Robert Terry - Polywell Fusion Reactors - 19th Annual International Mars Society Convention
Play Video

Dr. Robert Terry - Polywell Fusion Reactors - 19th Annual International Mars Society Convention

2016/10/20
Wiffle Ball -  Short film
Play Video

Wiffle Ball - Short film

2009/01/08
The Large Polywell Reactor
Play Video

The Large Polywell Reactor

2012/12/03
Worlds Greatest Fruit Fly Trap!
Play Video

Worlds Greatest Fruit Fly Trap!

2012/10/13
Wiffle Ball Stadium
Play Video

Wiffle Ball Stadium

2006/08/21
Heavy Ion Fusion
Play Video

Heavy Ion Fusion

2010/11/30
2007 Williamstown Wiffleball League Home Run Derby
Play Video

2007 Williamstown Wiffleball League Home Run Derby

2008/05/31
Double Horse 9116 Servo Control with Hall-Effect(magnetic strength) Sensor
Play Video

Double Horse 9116 Servo Control with Hall-Effect(magnetic strength) Sensor

2013/05/14
Balls
Play Video

Balls 'N Strikes: A Wiffleball Documentary

2008/04/22
Fusion 1.0
Play Video

Fusion 1.0

2007/11/29
Wiffle Ball Repair
Play Video

Wiffle Ball Repair

2009/04/07
Polywell Nuclear Fusion Reactor 3D
Play Video

Polywell Nuclear Fusion Reactor 3D

2008/03/14
Making A MLB  Phiten Tornado Necklace
Play Video

Making A MLB Phiten Tornado Necklace

2008/07/15
Powered by YouTube