Analysis of the Bussards Polywell (Part 3 of 3)

"Someday, they said, if they're right, a machine just 20 times bigger could run the city of Santa Fe." - The Santa Fe News Imagine if you could spend 200,000 dollars on a machine, which satisfied all your energy needs. Imagine there was a machine which produced bountiful electricity with no carbon footprint and no radiation. Imagine if that machine held the capacity to make space exploration a real possibility. If that were true, then such a machine would be the greatest invention of our time. That is a big IF. That is the claim that Dr. Robert Bussard is making with his Polywell device. He is claiming that he has designed a machine which will create bountiful energy, with no radiation and no carbon footprint. Such a claim is hard to stomach. It is hard to believe. This video attempts to take a hard look at this claim. Where does it make sense? Where does it falter? How valid is it, from a rough engineering analysis. This is by no means comprehensive. I do not claim to be an expert. Hopefully, this will spark a conversation, and further investigation by honest experts, into this validity of this device. -------------- Ideally, you want the kinetic pressure of the electrons balanced by the magnetic field pressure. Bussard made a ratio out of these: This is his beta condition, which he references at Google, and in his Valencia paper. The highest beta can reach is 1; at beta equals 1 condition, the Whiffle ball containment is formed. Above one and any extra electrons would simply escape the containment at the holes of the Whiffle Ball. Bussard claims that these hole sizes are 1.5-2 times the electron gyro radii at whatever energy level they are at. Computer simulations were done, examining this Whiffle ball effect, a picture of this effect is shown below: This work was done by a hobbyist, Indrek Mandre, in Estonia, in 2007. Indrek created simulations and animations of the magnetic fields, the electron and proton movement inside the reactor. Bussard makes reference to a 1.5-dimensional Vlasov-Maxwell code. In his Valencia paper, Bussard states that Whiffle ball confinement is critical to net power. Mr. Mandre said that his simulation would not get the Whiffle Ball effect; however he lacked the technical training, computer power, and completeness of model to simulate the effect properly. Mr. Mandre did form a cloud of electrons in the center, achieving a virtual cathode. This cathode could not create the 10 kV (with a 12.5 kV drive voltage) potential drop that Bussard claimed. This number seemed so high that Indrek did not believe it. Bussard claims that he can reach such a high potential drop because of the critical Whiffle ball effect. Many physicists see this as the biggest issue with the Polywell machine. On November 9th 2005, Dr. Bussard got 2.5E9 fusion reactions per second, for 0.4 milliseconds. He fused deuterium and deuterium (the easiest fusion reaction possible). The device ran on 12.5 kilovolts, with a well of 10 kV. He got this well by biasing his core with about 1E6 more electrons then protons. His magnetic field strength was 1300 Gauss, his vacuum was about 10E-9 Torr. The device used had a diameter of 30 cm. Because the electrons were moving at 10^9 cm/second theyre on a deferent time scale causing their lifetime to be 0.1 microsecond. This implies that the mean recirculation path of an electron in the reactor is 1/1000 of a centimeter.

2008/10/10 CleanEnergyFuture45   Share on Facebook

RELATED VIDEOS

Analysisof the Bussards
Play Video

Analysisof the Bussards' Polywell Idea (Part 1 of 3)

2008/10/10
The Polywell 101
Play Video

The Polywell 101

2013/05/22
Analysis of the Bussards Polywell  (Part 2 of 3)
Play Video

Analysis of the Bussards Polywell (Part 2 of 3)

2008/10/10
IEC Fusion vs Tokamak Fusion
Play Video

IEC Fusion vs Tokamak Fusion

2007/05/10
Fusion In A Basement
Play Video

Fusion In A Basement

2014/10/19
Polywell Fusion in 6 Steps :-)
Play Video

Polywell Fusion in 6 Steps :-)

2012/11/26
Path of an electron inside the cube polywell
Play Video

Path of an electron inside the cube polywell

2007/06/12
Polywell - Video Learning - WizScience.com
Play Video

Polywell - Video Learning - WizScience.com

2015/09/05
The Commercial Polywell Reactor
Play Video

The Commercial Polywell Reactor

2012/12/05
Building a homemade magnetic confinement fusion reactor
Play Video

Building a homemade magnetic confinement fusion reactor

2012/01/13
Polywell simulation 3D
Play Video

Polywell simulation 3D

2007/06/02
Heavy Watergate: The War on Cold Fusion
Play Video

Heavy Watergate: The War on Cold Fusion

2009/11/12
Should Google Go Nuclear? Clean, cheap, nuclear power...
Play Video

Should Google Go Nuclear? Clean, cheap, nuclear power...

2007/10/09
Polywell Fusion: Electrostatic Fusion in a Magnetic Cusp
Play Video

Polywell Fusion: Electrostatic Fusion in a Magnetic Cusp

2016/08/04
Polywell simulation 2D
Play Video

Polywell simulation 2D

2007/06/02
2007 Google Tech Talk: Focus Fusion - The Fastest Route to Cheap, Clean Energy?
Play Video

2007 Google Tech Talk: Focus Fusion - The Fastest Route to Cheap, Clean Energy?

2011/04/21
Open Source Nuclear Fusion
Play Video

Open Source Nuclear Fusion

2012/04/04
IEC Fusion for Dummies v5.7
Play Video

IEC Fusion for Dummies v5.7

2007/05/27
Polywell fusion simulation with CUDA (V2)
Play Video

Polywell fusion simulation with CUDA (V2)

2015/10/01
Polywell Nuclear Fusion Reactor 3D Simulation
Play Video

Polywell Nuclear Fusion Reactor 3D Simulation

2008/04/17
Part 3/4: Fusion taking focus - The Fall 2010 update!
Play Video

Part 3/4: Fusion taking focus - The Fall 2010 update!

2010/10/15
The Large Polywell Reactor
Play Video

The Large Polywell Reactor

2012/12/03
Electrostatically Unbalanced Magnetrons.wmv
Play Video

Electrostatically Unbalanced Magnetrons.wmv

2009/12/07
Play Video

'Crowdfunding' a Nuclear Device in NYC

2010/08/01
Aneutronic Nuclear Fusion Reactor + Engine Proposal
Play Video

Aneutronic Nuclear Fusion Reactor + Engine Proposal

2013/05/31
Hot Clean Fusion Energy Device
Play Video

Hot Clean Fusion Energy Device

2008/10/19
IEC Fusion for Dummies v5
Play Video

IEC Fusion for Dummies v5

2007/05/08
Nuclear Fusion video from National Geographic
Play Video

Nuclear Fusion video from National Geographic

2008/03/01
Dr. Robert Terry - Polywell Fusion Reactors - 19th Annual International Mars Society Convention
Play Video

Dr. Robert Terry - Polywell Fusion Reactors - 19th Annual International Mars Society Convention

2016/10/20
polywell sim   ion time scale   semi artificial anode, ions only 1
Play Video

polywell sim ion time scale semi artificial anode, ions only 1

2010/11/24
Fusion Reactor First Test Run
Play Video

Fusion Reactor First Test Run

2008/04/05
Part 4/4: Fusion taking focus - The Fall 2010 update!
Play Video

Part 4/4: Fusion taking focus - The Fall 2010 update!

2010/10/15
Demonstration Fusion Reactor Test 2
Play Video

Demonstration Fusion Reactor Test 2

2017/01/12
Fusion reaction
Play Video

Fusion reaction

2008/01/03
Upgrade to the Van de Graaff
Play Video

Upgrade to the Van de Graaff

2012/10/16
How to Design and Make Buttons : How to Make Drawn Squares Look 3-D for a Button
Play Video

How to Design and Make Buttons : How to Make Drawn Squares Look 3-D for a Button

2008/02/26
Polywell B150L2-i7 Review
Play Video

Polywell B150L2-i7 Review

2016/01/28
Polywell Model One, by Convergent Scientific
Play Video

Polywell Model One, by Convergent Scientific

2014/01/01
Sports Tutor PolyBall Wiffle Ball Pitching Machine
Play Video

Sports Tutor PolyBall Wiffle Ball Pitching Machine

2010/05/14
Electrons on Parade pt 1 - RCA
Play Video

Electrons on Parade pt 1 - RCA

2009/02/02
Mark Suppes: I still don
Play Video

Mark Suppes: I still don't know everything I should | WIRED 2012 | WIRED

2012/11/23
Everything Happens for a Reason (with Adam Savage)
Play Video

Everything Happens for a Reason (with Adam Savage)

2012/04/11
Visiting a Newborn Farnsworth Fusor at LMU
Play Video

Visiting a Newborn Farnsworth Fusor at LMU

2010/09/07
Make Labs Demo Fusor At Maker Faire Bay Area 2013
Play Video

Make Labs Demo Fusor At Maker Faire Bay Area 2013

2013/11/04
IEC Demo Fusor (Inertial electrostatic confinement)
Play Video

IEC Demo Fusor (Inertial electrostatic confinement)

2013/06/04
Hydrogen From the Sun
Play Video

Hydrogen From the Sun

2010/01/17
Geek Group Farnsworth-Hirsch-Meeks Fusor
Play Video

Geek Group Farnsworth-Hirsch-Meeks Fusor

2010/07/13
My Homemade Farnsworth - Warehouse 13
Play Video

My Homemade Farnsworth - Warehouse 13

2013/07/19
Powered by YouTube