Analysisof the Bussards' Polywell Idea (Part 1 of 3)

"Someday, they said, if they're right, a machine just 20 times bigger could run the city of Santa Fe." - The Santa Fe News Imagine if you could spend 200,000 dollars on a machine, which satisfied all your energy needs. Imagine there was a machine which produced bountiful electricity with no carbon footprint and no radiation. Imagine if that machine held the capacity to make space exploration a real possibility. If that were true, then such a machine would be the greatest invention of our time. That is a big IF. That is the claim that Dr. Robert Bussard is making with his Polywell device. He is claiming that he has designed a machine which will create bountiful energy, with no radiation and no carbon footprint. Such a claim is hard to stomach. It is hard to believe. This video attempts to take a hard look at this claim. Where does it make sense? Where does it falter? How valid is it, from a rough engineering analysis. This is by no means comprehensive. I do not claim to be an expert. Hopefully, this will spark a conversation, and further investigation by honest experts, into this validity of this device. ------ IEC fusion is normally done with metal cages. The inner cage is negatively charged, and the outer cage is positively charged. This creates a voltage drop, just like in a battery. Protons see the negative center, fly in and crash into one another at the center, causing fusion. Why dont we pursue this as an answer to all our fusion needs? These devices take more energy then they could ever make. The metal cages kill the devices efficiency. This is why they were always excused by everyone as a dead end to power generation. However, they can be used for other things. Researchers at the University of Wisconsin-Madison have been investigating IEC devices as a way to dispose of nuclear waste. They can burn nuclear waste in an IEC device. As was stated above, these devices always fail because of their metal cages. In 1984, Dr. Robert Bussard devised an IEC device which does not contain any metal grids. This device was called a polywell. In 2005, Dr. Bussard claimed to have achieved the world record for fusion using internal electrostatic fusion. This would be 200,000 times better than the previous record. Beyond this, Bussard claimed that the physical principals behind such a device were settled, thus paving the way for a pilot fusion power plant. This paper will offer a partial analysis of this concept, based on the claims made by Dr. Bussard. This is by no means a through analysis; its intent is to spark discussion about the validity of these claims. Analysis will mainly focus on looking for inconsistencies within Bussard own claims. In 1994 Todd Rider, did his doctorial thesis on all non-equilibrium plasma devices at MIT. Dr. Riders concluded that unless the reactor has highly efficient electron re-circulation, it will fail. "In virtually all cases, this minimum recirculation power is substantially larger than the fusion power, so barring discovery of methods for recirculation the power at exceedingly high efficiencies, reactors employing plasmas not in thermodynamic equilibrium will not be able to produce net power." (Rider, Thesis) It is clear; no efficient circulation of electrons and the machine fails. Riders work is often cited as the main argument against Bussards device. After investigation, it seems, Riders work does jive with Bussards. In the summer of 2005, Dr. Bussard came to the same conclusion rider did. In a letter he later recounted the discovery: The electrons can circulate out and back through the cusps all over the machine. Of course, this is obvious; but in 15 years no one saw it, not Hirsch, not our consultants not our opponents, not our staff, and not me." As it turns out, you needed 100,000 transits of electrons before you would get a fusion reaction. (Google Overview Paper). Why do you need re-circulation? Low energy electrons are re-excited by incoming high energy electrons; re-circulation conserves energy in the reactor. It also energizes the ion gas. 100,000 transits might be the high efficiencies Dr. Rider was referring too.

TARGET AD 2
2008/10/10 CleanEnergyFuture45   Share on Facebook

RELATED VIDEOS

2007 Google Tech Talk: Focus Fusion - The Fastest Route to Cheap, Clean Energy?
Play Video

2007 Google Tech Talk: Focus Fusion - The Fastest Route to Cheap, Clean Energy?

2011/04/21
Polywell Fusion: Electrostatic Fusion in a Magnetic Cusp
Play Video

Polywell Fusion: Electrostatic Fusion in a Magnetic Cusp

2016/08/04
The Polywell 101
Play Video

The Polywell 101

2013/05/22
Polywell Fusion in 6 Steps :-)
Play Video

Polywell Fusion in 6 Steps :-)

2012/11/26
Analysis of the Bussards Polywell  (Part 3 of 3)
Play Video

Analysis of the Bussards Polywell (Part 3 of 3)

2008/10/10
Analysis of the Bussards Polywell  (Part 2 of 3)
Play Video

Analysis of the Bussards Polywell (Part 2 of 3)

2008/10/10
Polywell fusion simulation with CUDA (V2)
Play Video

Polywell fusion simulation with CUDA (V2)

2015/10/01
Aneutronic Nuclear Fusion Reactor + Engine Proposal
Play Video

Aneutronic Nuclear Fusion Reactor + Engine Proposal

2013/05/31
Polywell simulation 3D
Play Video

Polywell simulation 3D

2007/06/02
Polywell - Video Learning - WizScience.com
Play Video

Polywell - Video Learning - WizScience.com

2015/09/05
Dr. Robert Terry - Polywell Fusion Reactors - 19th Annual International Mars Society Convention
Play Video

Dr. Robert Terry - Polywell Fusion Reactors - 19th Annual International Mars Society Convention

2016/10/20
The Large Polywell Reactor
Play Video

The Large Polywell Reactor

2012/12/03
Fusion Energy Production by Deuterium Particle Injection
Play Video

Fusion Energy Production by Deuterium Particle Injection

2012/09/28
Fusion reactor designed in hell makes its debut
Play Video

Fusion reactor designed in hell makes its debut

2015/10/21
15cm polywell 0.82 tesla phase space.wmv
Play Video

15cm polywell 0.82 tesla phase space.wmv

2010/12/02
Inertial Electrostatic Confinement Fusion Reactor Mk. II
Play Video

Inertial Electrostatic Confinement Fusion Reactor Mk. II

2011/03/31
Superfluid helium
Play Video

Superfluid helium

2007/08/05
Polywell Nuclear Fusion Reactor 3D Simulation
Play Video

Polywell Nuclear Fusion Reactor 3D Simulation

2008/04/17
Solar Energy - Nuclear Fusion in the Sun
Play Video

Solar Energy - Nuclear Fusion in the Sun

2011/10/22
Play Video

'Crowdfunding' a Nuclear Device in NYC

2010/08/01
The Liquid Fluoride Thorium Reactor:  What Fusion Wanted To Be
Play Video

The Liquid Fluoride Thorium Reactor: What Fusion Wanted To Be

2008/11/20
The Mystery of our Declining Genes Dr John Sanford
Play Video

The Mystery of our Declining Genes Dr John Sanford

2011/02/18
My Demonstration IEC Nuclear Fusion Reactor
Play Video

My Demonstration IEC Nuclear Fusion Reactor

2010/03/02
Focus Fusion: The Fastest Route to Cheap, Clean Energy
Play Video

Focus Fusion: The Fastest Route to Cheap, Clean Energy

2012/08/22
Fusion Particle Simulation with CUDA
Play Video

Fusion Particle Simulation with CUDA

2012/07/18
Path of an electron inside the cube polywell
Play Video

Path of an electron inside the cube polywell

2007/06/12
Electron path manipulation in a helmholtz coil
Play Video

Electron path manipulation in a helmholtz coil

2012/03/14
Fission is the New Fire
Play Video

Fission is the New Fire

2007/07/25
Part 3/4: Fusion taking focus - The Fall 2010 update!
Play Video

Part 3/4: Fusion taking focus - The Fall 2010 update!

2010/10/15
The Commercial Polywell Reactor
Play Video

The Commercial Polywell Reactor

2012/12/05
My Tokamak Reactor - 1
Play Video

My Tokamak Reactor - 1

2006/11/18
Daniel Kahneman: "Thinking, Fast and Slow" | Talks at Google
Play Video

Daniel Kahneman: "Thinking, Fast and Slow" | Talks at Google

2011/11/11
CrossFire Fusor - Aneutronic Nuclear Fusion Reactor
Play Video

CrossFire Fusor - Aneutronic Nuclear Fusion Reactor

2008/12/16
polywell sim   ion time scale   semi artificial anode, ions only 1
Play Video

polywell sim ion time scale semi artificial anode, ions only 1

2010/11/24
Fusion Reactor Overview
Play Video

Fusion Reactor Overview

2008/04/05
IEC Fusion vs Tokamak Fusion
Play Video

IEC Fusion vs Tokamak Fusion

2007/05/10
Should Google Go Nuclear? Clean, cheap, nuclear power...
Play Video

Should Google Go Nuclear? Clean, cheap, nuclear power...

2007/10/09
SolidWorks Tutorials by SolidProfessor Rack and Pinion Mate
Play Video

SolidWorks Tutorials by SolidProfessor Rack and Pinion Mate

2007/03/12
We
Play Video

We're Close To Harnessing Nuclear Fusion

2013/10/11
Bernoulli Effect Display
Play Video

Bernoulli Effect Display

2009/05/12
The Discovery of the Electron (2 of 15)
Play Video

The Discovery of the Electron (2 of 15)

2008/03/01
When Will Time End? (Version 1)
Play Video

When Will Time End? (Version 1)

2009/11/11
Nuclear Fusion
Play Video

Nuclear Fusion

2007/08/06
9. Periodic trends
Play Video

9. Periodic trends

2009/07/01
A History of Spherical Tokamaks
Play Video

A History of Spherical Tokamaks

2018/02/02
Lec 1 | MIT 5.111 Principles of Chemical Science, Fall 2005
Play Video

Lec 1 | MIT 5.111 Principles of Chemical Science, Fall 2005

2008/01/18
Powered by YouTube

Disclaimer

None of the audio/visual content is hosted on this site. All media is embedded from other sites such as GoogleVideo, YouTube etc. Therefore, this site has no control over the copyright issues of the streaming media.

All issues concerning copyright violations should be aimed at the sites hosting the material. This site does not host any of the streaming media and the owner has not uploaded any of the material to the video hosting servers. Anyone can find the same content on Google Video or YouTube by themselves.

The owner of this site cannot know which documentaries are in public domain, which has been uploaded to e.g. YouTube by the owner and which has been uploaded without permission. The copyright owner must contact the source if he wants his material off the Internet completely.