The truth about why Tesla can't save the planet - and neither can other EVs

Why electric cars don’t matter, and can’t help. There is no doubt about global warming. There is no doubt that it is humanity causing this problem. It’s a serious problem, and it’s not a matter of belief. You don’t get to choose sides on this. We need to address this literally burning issue urgently - for our own sakes. (The planet’s gunna be OK.) Humanity is on the line. Here in ‘Straya the Department of the Environment and Energy produces an annual greenhouse gas inventory to an internationally agreed set of reporting standards. The latest report says that we, as a nation, emitted 533 million tonnes of CO2-equivalent in 2015 - that’s up 27 per cent in 25 years, despite having 41 per cent population growth in the same time. Passenger cars are responsible for 44 million tonnes - out of 533 - or about eight per cent of total emissions. So even if electric cars were a breathtaking panacea for those problematic passenger car emissions, we really would not be ameliorating the greenhouse emission problem in a significant way by deploying them widely. The big emitter here: Electricity. Number one with a bullet - 192 million tonnes. That’s 36 per cent of the problem overall and materially almost four-and-a-half times bigger than emissions from passenger cars. I’m certain the car is demonised disproportionately, compared with running the air conditioning, having four refrigerators, or living in a house four times bigger than you need. Unfortunately, if you want to make a dent in a problem, you must first acquire good data. And, inconveniently, the facts are so annoyingly, routinely, out of alignment with our beliefs. I’ll break down transport in Australia for you. Total transport emissions: 92 million tonnes. Passenger cars: 44. Trucks: 23. Every other mode of transport: 25. We drive a helluva long way in ‘Straya. According to Ausstats, passenger vehicles drove 176 billion kilometres in 2016. That’s almost 12 return trips to Pluto. So, instead of driving to Pluto again, let’s do what Einstein would call a thought experiment. Let’s have Elon Musk channel his inner Oprah Winfrey and give us all a free Model S - the shitbox poverty one - the 75D. You get a 75D. You get a 75D. Etc - 13.7 million times. Because that’s how many passenger vehicles there are on Australian roads. The poverty Model S promises (quote) “up to 490km” from its 75 kilowatt-hour Panasonic battery pack. That’s awesome. Best-case scenario: About 15 kilowatt-hours for 100km. If you scale that up for our usual annual 12 return trips to Pluto, that’s about 27 billion kilowatt-hours of additional electricity we’d need. According to the World Nuclear Association, ‘Straya produced 258 billion kilowatt-hours of electricity in 2016. So we’d need slightly more than an extra 10 per cent total electricity to run our 13.7 million Oprah-style gifted poverty pack Model S 75D shitboxes. Shifting to a fleet of Teslas would add another 20 million tonnes. So, we magically erase 44 million tonnes of emissions … but we add back 20 million tonnes of additional CO2 from the additional electrical energy required. So, we’re 24 million tonnes in front. That’s a 4.5 per cent improvement. If we were instead to pay for those cars - they are $112,000 each, full retail, but I’d suggest if we ordered almost 14 million of them we’d get maybe a third off. That's one trillion dollars. For a hypothetical 4.5 per cent reduction in CO2 emissions. It’s ridiculous. There would have to be dozens of ways you could spend one trillion dollars to reduce CO2 emissions - such as building photovoltaic arrays and manufacturing hydrogen. This tells me - of course - that the only thing green about Tesla is the marketing. This is about cashing in on rich but dumb people’s good intentions - the desire to do the right thing for the future. It’s bullshit marketing par excellence… It’s obvious how we could cut global CO2 emissions by almost 600 million tonnes - and that’s more than our national total. It’s dead simple. We export three times as much thermal black coal - every year - as we burn onshore. (Data source: World Nuclear Association.) We could hypothetically cut 600 million tonnes of CO2 at a cost of $22 billion, versus spending one trillion dollars to save about 20 million tonnes of CO2 by all driving Teslas. That’s a statement about return on investment, national priorities and how we do business globally. And what it would take actually to get serious and tackle this problem. So-called clean coal. World’s most outrageous oxymoron.

TARGET AD 2
2017/12/25 AutoExpertTV   Share on Facebook

RELATED VIDEOS

What Jeremy Clarkson thinks about Tesla
Play Video

What Jeremy Clarkson thinks about Tesla

2017/11/28
How Much Oil is Left in the world? | Auto Expert John Cadogan | Australia
Play Video

How Much Oil is Left in the world? | Auto Expert John Cadogan | Australia

2017/08/22
Here
Play Video

Here's Why the Tesla Model X Is an Awful Car

2016/12/12
The Truth About the Tesla Semi Electric Truck | Auto Expert John Cadogan | Australia
Play Video

The Truth About the Tesla Semi Electric Truck | Auto Expert John Cadogan | Australia

2017/12/18
Climate Change Hoax Busted (We are causing it) | Auto Expert John Cadogan | Australia
Play Video

Climate Change Hoax Busted (We are causing it) | Auto Expert John Cadogan | Australia

2018/01/06
Frozen electric cars - a Leaf and a Tesla at -25C
Play Video

Frozen electric cars - a Leaf and a Tesla at -25C

2017/12/30
Top 10 Mercedes Benz Myths
Play Video

Top 10 Mercedes Benz Myths

2016/02/25
Everything wrong with Faraday Future’s “Tesla killer”
Play Video

Everything wrong with Faraday Future’s “Tesla killer”

2017/01/06
Car reliability: Turbos & timing belts | Auto Expert John Cadogan | Australia
Play Video

Car reliability: Turbos & timing belts | Auto Expert John Cadogan | Australia

2017/06/13
Why You Should Love Hydrocarbons | Auto Expert John Cadogan | Australia
Play Video

Why You Should Love Hydrocarbons | Auto Expert John Cadogan | Australia

2016/09/05
Nikola Tesla Greatest Secret EXPOSED - The One Thing He Said That NOBODY Mentions
Play Video

Nikola Tesla Greatest Secret EXPOSED - The One Thing He Said That NOBODY Mentions

2017/02/27
The Truth about Engine ECU Upgrades, Chips & Re-mapping | Auto Expert John Cadogan | Australia
Play Video

The Truth about Engine ECU Upgrades, Chips & Re-mapping | Auto Expert John Cadogan | Australia

2017/12/02
Testing The World
Play Video

Testing The World's Smartest Autonomous Car (NOT A Tesla)

2017/12/20
Top 10 Worst Car Design & Engineering Abominations | Auto Expert John Cadogan | Australia
Play Video

Top 10 Worst Car Design & Engineering Abominations | Auto Expert John Cadogan | Australia

2017/05/31
Electric Cars for 2018 Now Gaining Momentum! The Rise of Electric Cars Worldwide
Play Video

Electric Cars for 2018 Now Gaining Momentum! The Rise of Electric Cars Worldwide

2017/12/22
Hyundai i30 N: Volkswagen Golf GTI killer? Auto Expert John Cadogan | Australia
Play Video

Hyundai i30 N: Volkswagen Golf GTI killer? Auto Expert John Cadogan | Australia

2018/02/24
Engine Oil Diluted With Fuel (the facts for 2018)
Play Video

Engine Oil Diluted With Fuel (the facts for 2018)

2017/12/09
Tesla knew Gravity was just a bogus theory and that Einstein was a shill
Play Video

Tesla knew Gravity was just a bogus theory and that Einstein was a shill

2016/04/28
Nikola Tesla Interview Hidden For 116 Years - Incredible
Play Video

Nikola Tesla Interview Hidden For 116 Years - Incredible

2017/06/27
Is Tesla a cult? The inconvenient truth about electric cars.
Play Video

Is Tesla a cult? The inconvenient truth about electric cars.

2017/07/23
The Truth About Speedo Accuracy | Auto Expert John Cadogan | Australia
Play Video

The Truth About Speedo Accuracy | Auto Expert John Cadogan | Australia

2017/12/01
Don
Play Video

Don't buy a Volvo XC60: It's Bullshit Car of the Year | Auto Expert John Cadogan | Australia

2018/01/26
The Truth About The Tesla Semi-Truck
Play Video

The Truth About The Tesla Semi-Truck

2017/12/15
2018 Jeep Grand Cherokee Trackhawk (Why I love it but would never buy one)
Play Video

2018 Jeep Grand Cherokee Trackhawk (Why I love it but would never buy one)

2017/12/13
This trick got me banned from selling cars on eBay for life
Play Video

This trick got me banned from selling cars on eBay for life

2017/12/22
Dealer Selling Flood Cars with "NO Evidence of Water ANYWHERE" Exposed!
Play Video

Dealer Selling Flood Cars with "NO Evidence of Water ANYWHERE" Exposed!

2017/12/25
Top 3 Worst ever Automotive Engineering Component Names | Auto Expert John Cadogan | Australia
Play Video

Top 3 Worst ever Automotive Engineering Component Names | Auto Expert John Cadogan | Australia

2017/11/15
The truth about premium diesel fuel | Auto Expert John Cadogan | Australia
Play Video

The truth about premium diesel fuel | Auto Expert John Cadogan | Australia

2017/12/03
2018 Holden Don
Play Video

2018 Holden Don't Buy Warning | Auto Expert John Cadogan Australia

2018/02/11
Does The Tesla Roadster Really Have 7,000+ lb-ft Of Torque?!
Play Video

Does The Tesla Roadster Really Have 7,000+ lb-ft Of Torque?!

2017/12/23
2018 VW Polo -Vs- Choosing the right new car | Auto Expert John Cadogan
Play Video

2018 VW Polo -Vs- Choosing the right new car | Auto Expert John Cadogan

2018/01/27
10 Car Mods BANNED in America!
Play Video

10 Car Mods BANNED in America!

2018/02/05
2018 Subaru XV Review (A.K.A. Subaru Crosstrek) | Auto Expert John Cadogan | Australia
Play Video

2018 Subaru XV Review (A.K.A. Subaru Crosstrek) | Auto Expert John Cadogan | Australia

2017/10/08
2018 Subaru WRX STI Review | Auto Expert John Cadogan | Australia
Play Video

2018 Subaru WRX STI Review | Auto Expert John Cadogan | Australia

2017/11/27
Here
Play Video

Here's Why the Tesla Model 3 Is the Coolest Car of 2017

2017/11/06
The truth about Kia Stinger
Play Video

The truth about Kia Stinger's 3-star safety rating | Auto Expert John Cadogan | Australia

2018/01/01
2018 Subaru WRX Review | Auto Expert John Cadogan | Australia
Play Video

2018 Subaru WRX Review | Auto Expert John Cadogan | Australia

2018/01/12
The truth about Hyundai
Play Video

The truth about Hyundai's court enforceable undertaking with the ACCC | Auto Expert John Cadogan

2018/02/09
The truth about painting your intercooler black | Auto Expert John Cadogan | Australia
Play Video

The truth about painting your intercooler black | Auto Expert John Cadogan | Australia

2017/12/28
What really happens if I don
Play Video

What really happens if I don't get my car serviced?

2017/12/10
Tesla Motors - The Car Company They
Play Video

Tesla Motors - The Car Company They're Scared Of And Why

2014/02/15
Nikola Tesla: Nobody knows my story. It
Play Video

Nikola Tesla: Nobody knows my story. It's Time to tell you EVERYTHING

2017/09/15
The dark side of the electric car revolution 🇨🇬 | Counting the Cost
Play Video

The dark side of the electric car revolution 🇨🇬 | Counting the Cost

2017/12/24
Car Dealership revenge (how to win) | Auto Expert John Cadogan | Australia
Play Video

Car Dealership revenge (how to win) | Auto Expert John Cadogan | Australia

2018/01/04
What you said about the Tesla Semi truck launch (warning: contains Nuts)
Play Video

What you said about the Tesla Semi truck launch (warning: contains Nuts)

2017/12/21
$54,000 Tesla Model 3!! What Options I Chose and Why
Play Video

$54,000 Tesla Model 3!! What Options I Chose and Why

2017/12/25
2018 Kia Sorento GT-Line Review | Auto Expert John Cadogan | Australia
Play Video

2018 Kia Sorento GT-Line Review | Auto Expert John Cadogan | Australia

2017/11/19
Powered by YouTube

Disclaimer

None of the audio/visual content is hosted on this site. All media is embedded from other sites such as GoogleVideo, YouTube etc. Therefore, this site has no control over the copyright issues of the streaming media.

All issues concerning copyright violations should be aimed at the sites hosting the material. This site does not host any of the streaming media and the owner has not uploaded any of the material to the video hosting servers. Anyone can find the same content on Google Video or YouTube by themselves.

The owner of this site cannot know which documentaries are in public domain, which has been uploaded to e.g. YouTube by the owner and which has been uploaded without permission. The copyright owner must contact the source if he wants his material off the Internet completely.